They Live in Guinea
Elementary Lesson Two



Procedure


Synopsis

Viewing Time: 12 minutes. Start with the shot of the sign at Buck's store. End with the scene of the waterman in the shed tallying the count. The man is seen in the window of the shed.

Changes in the Area

Buck Rowe says life has changed in Guinea since his father opened the store in 1920. In 1950, the Coleman bridge between Gloucester and Yorktown was built.

Dave explains that the rapid development of the area has caused difficulties for the seafood industry. Pollution, shellfish disease, loss of habitat had almost wiped out the oysters. The State regulatory body, the Virginia Marine Resource Commission, closed the harvest completely to let the oysters repopulate.

The Watermen's Problems

Some of the watermen felt that closing the river was the wrong thing to do. It caused hardships for the watermen. The men on the commission didn't know the river as well as the watermen. There were oysters that needed to be harvested. (This discussion continues after the footage of the Kellums' boat.)

Billy Kellum's Boat

In spite of the difficulties, Billy Kellum and his step-son, Derek, are building a deadrise workboat by hand. The boat measures 47 'long, 14'6" wide, 13'4" at the stern, with a deadrise of 40". They plan to use it for clamming. Billy doesn't have any plans to follow while making the boat. He knows how to make it without writing everything down. He thinks the wooden boat has more personality than a fiberglass one, and is also stronger.

Discussion About Regulation

Buck sees employment as the problem. Jobs are scarce now. There used to be more watermen. There aren't many oysters, crabs, or clams. There has been regulation of the industry since the mid 1800s. Regulations include: licensing, limited fishing season, restrictions on the types of gear and the size of the seafood caught, quotas on the amount of seafood, and reporting requirements. Watermen have always objected to the government's meddling in the details of how they make their living. The resentment now is particularly bitter.

The watermen organized to prove to the commission and the media that the thick beds of oysters needed to be worked. They were successful and the commission overturned their decision and reopened the James River. (Old footage of the area follows this statement.)

Ronnie and Linda Crewe discuss regulation with Ray. Ray thinks they should leave everything alone the way it was. He didn't think there were any problems before. Ronnie and Linda feel the regulation had to happen. Tommy thinks the best thing for the watermen to do is get involved and have their voices heard. Ray says, "The Man upstairs has got all to do with working on the water. If He wants, it's gonna be. If not, it's not."

There are now more oysters than anyone remembers seeing for the last twenty years. However, there used to be about 150 market boats, and now there is just one.

Before Viewing

Ask the students to share what they know about the current problems with the marine life in the Chesapeake Bay. Tell them this section of the video discusses the problems the watermen are having. Encourage them to listen to find out how the various people feel, and what is being done to solve the problem. Write the vocabulary words on the board. Read the contextual sentences aloud to students and help them determine the meaning of the words. Encourage them to listen for the vocabulary words in the video.

During Viewing

Distribute copies of the Video Note-Taking Form. Explain that the students will individually take brief notes or draw pictures on the left side of the page either during or immediately after watching the video. Suggest that they jot down key terms, names, dates, and any questions they may have. Notes should be taken in sequential order.

Show the second section of the video.

After Viewing

After watching the video, have students work in previously established small groups to extend each other's information. Students may want to take turns reading their individual notes aloud or showing their pictures so that other members of the group can add information they may have missed. All new information should be recorded on the right hand side of the Video Note-Taking Form.

Summary

Meet with the whole class and then develop the post-graphic organizer to summarize key points from this section of the video. Help students identify the major topics. At this point, you may wish to re-play the video tape or continue on with other activities.



Extensions Lesson Two

I. Vocabulary

Write the words and sentences on the board. Ask students to read them and think about what the words might mean. Supply the definitions. Tell students to listen for the words in the video.
regulatory The State regulatory body, the Virginia Marine Resource Commission, took drastic measures.
(Controlling by law.) adjective
drastic The State Regulatory body, the Virginia Marine Resource Commission, took drastic measures.
(Severe; extreme.) adjective

II. Notetaking-Form 2

III. Post Graphic Organizer 2

IV. Projects

  1. Make a poster protesting or supporting the closing of the James River.

  2. Draw a picture of a favorite part of the video.

  3. Talk to an adult about the video. Ask what they think of having the government regulate the seafood catches.

  4. Make a poster comparing and contrasting the Chesapeake Bay in 1964 and now.

  5. Write an acrostic poem about this section of the video.


Assessment Lesson Two

Suggestions: 1) Discuss the questions with the whole class. 2) Assign one question to each student or pair of students. Have them present the answers to the class. 3) Choose a few of the questions and have students write the answers.

Points for Discussion

  1. How has the area changed since the 1920s, when Buck's father first opened the store?

  2. What are some of the signs of progress in the area?

  3. What was the biggest difference in Gloucester County from 1920 to 1995?

  4. What music is playing in this section of the video? Why do you think the producers chose this music?

  5. How did mot people get from Gloucester to Yorktown before 1950?

  6. How do most people get from Gloucester to Yorktown now?

  7. What problems does the oyster business have now?

  8. What did the state do to try to help solve the problems?

  9. How do the watermen feel about the state's regulations?

  10. Why do the watermen throw the old oyster shells back into the water?

  11. How do the watermen get the oysters from the bottom ohe river?

  12. What are Billy Kellum and Derek doing to keep the old way of life?

  13. How many oysters were in the James River at the time this video was made, in 1994 ?

Top of Lesson 2